Sleep vs Magnesium+: Which One Do You Actually Need?

True Protein Blog Avatar Fallback reviewed by our Nutrition Team Published: 09 September 2026 Updated: 09 September 2026

Magnesium+ and Sleep both contain magnesium, but they're built for two completely different jobs, and two different times of day.

Sleep vs Magnesium+: Which One Do You Actually Need?

Summary

Magnesium+ and Sleep are both magnesium-based, but they do two different jobs. Magnesium+ is a daily recovery blend you can take at any time of day to support muscle function and stress resilience. Sleep is a dedicated night-time formula built around glycine, magnesium and L-theanine to help you wind down, settle faster and recover overnight.

If you're deciding between them, or wondering whether you can take both, here's how they differ, and how to fit them into your routine.

 

What is Magnesium+, and what does it do?

Magnesium+ is an everyday magnesium supplement designed to be taken whenever it suits you. Each 5g serve delivers 2.8g of magnesium citrate, a highly soluble form of magnesium that mixes clearly and is well absorbed, alongside glutamine, zinc and vitamin B6.

Magnesium is a cofactor in more than 300 enzyme systems in the body, including those governing muscle contraction, nerve transmission, protein synthesis and energy production. In plain English: it's involved in almost everything your body does to repair itself and keep functioning normally, which is why running low tends to show up as fatigue, muscle cramping and poor recovery rather than one specific symptom.

The supporting ingredients each have a defined role:

  • Glutamine — the most abundant amino acid in the body, used heavily during periods of physical stress and training load.
  • Zinc — an essential mineral involved in immune function and protein synthesis.
  • Vitamin B6 — required for protein and amino acid metabolism, and for magnesium's transport into cells.

Magnesium+ comes in Natural, Lemon Burst, Pineapple & Blood Orange, in a 250g bag (50 serves) and a 5g single-serve sachet.

 

What is Sleep, and what does it do?

Sleep is our first dedicated night-time formula. It isn't a magnesium supplement with a bedtime label on it, it's a different formula, built around ingredients with evidence behind them specifically for the hours between lights-out and waking up.

Each 10g serve (natural) contains:

Sleep comes in Natural, Mixed Berry & Tropical, in a 300g satchel (30 serves).

 

What's the actual difference between Sleep and Magnesium+?


 Magnesium+ Sleep
Job Daily recovery and stress resilience Night-time wind-down and overnight recovery
When to take it Any time of day 30–60 minutes before bed
Serve size 5g 10g
Magnesium source Magnesium citrate Magnesium citrate
Key actives Magnesium, glutamine, zinc, vitamin B6 Glycine, collagen, magnesium, L-theanine, taurine, tart cherry
Best for Training load, cramping, general magnesium intake Trouble winding down, restless nights, overnight repair
Flavours Natural, Blood Orange, Lemon Burst, Pineapple Natural, Tropical, Mixed Berry

 

Can I take Sleep and Magnesium+ together?

Yes, but space them out rather than taking them at the same time.

Sleep already contains a meaningful dose of magnesium, so there's no need to double up in the evening. If you'd like both in your routine, take Magnesium+ in the morning or the middle of the day, and keep Sleep for the evening.

When does Magnesium+ make the most sense?

Magnesium+ is particularly useful after a morning training session where you've sweated a lot, or on days with a heavy training load. Magnesium is lost through sweat, and requirements sit higher for people training regularly than for the general population.

When should I take Sleep?

Around 30 to 60 minutes before bed. The glycine research used a similar window, the studies above gave participants glycine roughly an hour before bedtime.

 

Do I need both, or will one do the job?

Most people don't need both. Start with the one that matches the problem you're actually trying to solve.

Choose Magnesium+ if:

  • You want a straightforward daily magnesium supplement
  • You're training regularly and want support for muscle function and recovery
  • You'd rather take it in the morning or with lunch than at night

Choose Sleep if:

  • Winding down is the harder part of your day
  • You wake through the night or don't feel recovered in the morning
  • You want overnight sleep support

Consider both if:

  • You train hard in the morning and struggle to switch off at night, in which case, Magnesium+ early, Sleep late.

Key Takeaways

  • Magnesium+ is a daily recovery blend that can be taken at any time of day; Sleep is a dedicated night-time formula taken 30–60 minutes before bed.
  • Sleep is built around 3g of glycine and 200mg of L-theanine, both of which have research behind them for sleep quality specifically.
  • Both products contain magnesium citrate, so taking them at the same time means doubling up unnecessarily.
  • If you use both, take Magnesium+ in the morning or middle of the day — particularly after a sweaty session — and keep Sleep for the evening.
  • Most people only need one: choose Magnesium+ for daily recovery, Sleep for night-time wind-down.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it safe to take Sleep and Magnesium+ on the same day?

Yes, provided you space them out, Magnesium+ earlier in the day, Sleep in the evening. Taking both at once means doubling up on magnesium unnecessarily. If you take prescription medication or have a health condition, speak with your GP or pharmacist first.

Can I just take Magnesium+ before bed instead of Sleep?

You can, and many people find this works for them. But you'd be missing the ingredients Sleep has to offer (glycine, L-theanine, taurine and tart cherry), which are designed to support the wind-down process specifically.

Does Sleep contain melatonin?

Not as an added ingredient. Sleep contains tart cherry powder, which is a natural food source of melatonin. Supplemental melatonin is a prescription medicine in Australia and isn't used in our formula.

Will Sleep make me groggy in the morning?

Sleep doesn't contain sedatives. The glycine research found the opposite, participants reported less daytime sleepiness the following day, not more.

What's the best time of day to take magnesium?

Whenever you'll take it consistently. Magnesium doesn't need to be taken at night to work, the association with bedtime is habit rather than physiology.

IMPORTANT INFORMATION: all content provided here is of a general nature only and is not a substitute for individualised professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment and reliance should not be placed on it. For personalised medical or nutrition advice, please make an appointment with your doctor, dietitian or qualified healthcare professional.